Home › MCQs › Education › Question #6777
Back to Questions
Education QUESTION #6777
Question 1
A teacher asks students to sort unseen essay papers by quality (best to worst), then assigns grades based on relative rank. According to holistic rubric theory, which grading philosophy does this approach embody, and what is its key limitation?
  • Criterion-referenced philosophy; it lacks discriminating power
  • Norm-referenced philosophy; papers are ranked relative to each other rather than against absolute quality criteria, which makes it unsuitable for large numbers of papers✔️
  • Absolute standard philosophy; it can be applied consistently to any number of papers
  • Analytic philosophy; sub-criteria are implicitly weighted differently
Correct Answer Explanation
This is the fourth approach to holistic scoring — ranking papers relative to each other — which aligns with norm-referenced or relative standard grading. Its critical limitation: it cannot be applied to large sets of papers because it requires reading and comparing all papers simultaneously, and scores depend on the composition of the specific group rather than absolute quality.