Home › MCQs › Business Administration › Question #9608
Back to Questions
Business Administration QUESTION #9608
Question 1
A manager applies the 'Boston Consulting Group (BCG) matrix' and classifies a product as a 'Dog' (low market share, low market growth). The product has been in the portfolio for 8 years and generates modest but consistent positive cash flow. The BCG prescription is to divest. What critical limitation of the BCG matrix does this scenario expose?
  • The BCG matrix is only applicable to manufacturing firms — service sector 'dogs' often have strategic value that the matrix cannot capture
  • The BCG matrix uses only two dimensions (market share and market growth) and ignores strategic interdependencies — a 'dog' product may serve as a loss-leader, maintain a customer relationship that cross-sells other products, or occupy a niche that prevents competitor entry; divestiture based solely on BCG classification can destroy hidden strategic value✔️
  • The BCG matrix prescribes divestiture for all dogs regardless of competitive context — a more nuanced competitor analysis might reveal the product holds monopoly position in a stable niche
  • The BCG matrix's market growth axis uses industry average as the threshold, which may misclassify products in declining industries where even 'low growth' represents above-competitor performance
Correct Answer Explanation
The BCG matrix's two-dimensional simplicity is its greatest weakness. A dog generating consistent positive cash flow with strategic value (customer retention, competitive blocking, cross-selling platform) should not be divested on matrix prescription alone. The matrix ignores: product interdependencies, customer lifetime value, competitive dynamics within the specific niche, and cash flow quality. It is a portfolio screening tool, not a decision algorithm — a limitation widely acknowledged in strategic management literature.